Independent publication. We may earn a fee when you request information from a school or buy a course through links marked as sponsored. It never changes what we recommend. How we work
Toolkit

Growth Mindset Toolkit for Educators

What a growth mindset is, what the evidence does and does not show, and how to build it into everyday teaching, with a printable strategies guide and a student and family handout.

Updated November 7, 202614 min read

Students with a fixed mindset believe that intelligence and talent are set early and cannot change much. You hear it in phrases like "I'm just not a math person." Students with a growth mindset believe that abilities can be developed through effort, good strategies and help from others. The distinction comes from Stanford psychologist Carol Dweck, whose 2006 book Mindset: The New Psychology of Success brought decades of motivation research to a general audience.

This toolkit is for teachers, counselors and school leaders who want to move past posters and slogans. It covers what a growth mindset is and is not, what the evidence actually shows, 14 classroom strategies with grade-band notes, a six-week implementation sequence, ways to measure progress, and the pitfalls that turn growth mindset into an empty catchphrase. Two printable companions, a strategies guide and a student and family handout, are linked on this page.

What a growth mindset is (and is not)

A mindset is a belief about the nature of ability. In Dweck's framing, a fixed mindset treats intelligence as a trait you have a set amount of, while a growth mindset treats it as something that grows through learning. The belief matters because it shapes behavior under difficulty. When a task gets hard, a student who thinks ability is fixed reads the struggle as evidence of low ability and protects themselves by disengaging. A student who thinks ability grows reads the same struggle as the point where learning happens.

Three clarifications prevent most misunderstandings:

  • A growth mindset is not "effort is everything." Effort without a workable strategy and without feedback rarely produces progress. The growth mindset message is that ability develops through effort, strategies and support together.
  • It is not a personality type. Everyone holds fixed beliefs about some domains and growth beliefs about others, and the same student can shift depending on the subject, the teacher and the stakes.
  • It is not a substitute for good instruction. Mindset affects how students respond to challenge. It does not replace clear teaching, well-sequenced practice and timely feedback.

Both high-achieving and struggling students can hold either mindset. High achievers who have rarely failed can be the most vulnerable when they finally meet work that does not come easily.

What the research says about growth mindset

Growth mindset is one of the most studied and most debated ideas in education. A fair summary: the core findings have held up, the effects are smaller than early enthusiasm suggested, and the effects depend heavily on context.

Dweck's foundational studies

In six experiments published in 1998, Mueller and Dweck praised fifth graders either for intelligence or for effort after they succeeded on a set of problems. Children praised for intelligence went on to care more about performance goals than learning goals. After a failure they showed less persistence, less enjoyment, more attributions to low ability and worse performance than children praised for effort, and they described intelligence as a fixed trait more often. In a later article for ASCD, Dweck reported that almost 40 percent of the intelligence-praised students lied about their scores afterward, compared with about 10 percent of the effort-praised students.

A 2007 study by Blackwell, Trzesniewski and Dweck followed 373 students across two years of junior high. Students who believed intelligence could be developed showed rising math grades over the two years, while students who believed it was fixed showed flat grades, even though the groups started at similar levels. In a second study, an eight-session workshop that taught students that the brain grows with learning reversed a decline in math grades, while a control group that received the same study-skills content without the mindset message kept declining, as summarized in the research society's release.

The national experiment

The strongest test came from the National Study of Learning Mindsets, published in Nature in 2019 by David Yeager, Carol Dweck and colleagues. The study randomized 12,490 ninth graders across 65 US public high schools to a short online growth mindset program (two self-administered sessions of about 25 minutes each) or a control activity. Among lower-achieving students, the program raised core-course grade point average by 0.10 points, and across the sample it increased enrollment in Algebra II or higher in tenth grade from 33 percent to 36 percent. The University of Texas at Austin release added that the share of lower-achieving students with a D or F average in core courses fell by more than 5 percentage points.

The most important finding was about context. Grade effects were larger in schools where peer norms supported challenge-seeking, and smaller where they did not. A 2022 follow-up by Yeager and colleagues, using 9,167 student records matched to 223 math teachers, found that the program improved outcomes only when students' math teachers themselves held growth mindset beliefs. The authors call this the "mindset plus supportive context" hypothesis. Students cannot act on a growth mindset in a classroom that punishes mistakes.

An honest reading of the meta-analyses

In 2018, Sisk and colleagues pooled 273 effect sizes from 365,915 participants on the link between mindset and achievement, and 43 effect sizes from 57,155 participants on mindset interventions. Overall effects were weak in both analyses, though students with low socioeconomic status or at academic risk appeared to benefit more. Co-author Brooke Macnamara put it bluntly in the university release: the evidence for interventions improving achievement "is not strong."

A 2023 meta-analysis by Burnette and colleagues in Psychological Bulletin, as summarized in a commentary by Tipton and colleagues, found an overall academic effect of about 0.09 standard deviations, rising to 0.16 for targeted at-risk students, with wide variation across studies. A competing meta-analysis in the same issue put the overall figure at 0.05.

In a 2020 review in American Psychologist, Yeager and Dweck argue that effects of around 0.11 standard deviations for lower-achieving students are meaningful when an intervention costs less than an hour and reaches whole cohorts, and that variation across schools is a finding to explain rather than a failure to replicate. They also acknowledge that teacher-focused growth mindset professional development has not yet shown reliable effects.

What this means for your classroom

Three practical conclusions follow. First, the message matters most for students who are struggling or facing a transition such as the start of middle or high school. Second, a brief program cannot carry the load alone; the classroom has to make challenge-seeking and revision normal. Third, your own beliefs about your students are part of the intervention.

Research: The OECD's PISA 2018 assessment was the first to ask 15-year-olds whether they agreed that their intelligence is something they cannot change very much, across 78 countries and economies (OECD report page). According to the Fordham Institute's summary, almost two in three students disagreed, and those students scored about 31 points higher in reading, 27 in science and 23 in math after accounting for socioeconomic status. Students who said their teachers adapted lessons to the class were 3.5 percentage points more likely to hold a growth mindset.

Growth mindset in the classroom: 14 strategies

Each strategy below is written so you can use it this week. The printable companion repeats them with step-by-step instructions and language examples. Grade-band notes use K-2, 3-5, 6-8 and 9-12.

1. Teach how learning changes the brain

Students need a reason to believe ability grows. Spend one lesson on the idea that practice strengthens connections in the brain, the same content that Blackwell's eight-session workshop used. Keep it concrete: learning a skill is like building a path through a field; the more you walk it, the clearer it gets.

Grade band: K-2, use the path or muscle analogy with a drawing. 6-12, let students research one example of a skill they personally improved and explain what changed.

2. Praise the process, not the person

Replace "You're so smart" with specific feedback on strategy, decision or persistence: "You tried two methods before this one worked." The Mueller and Dweck studies show why person praise backfires after the first setback.

Grade band: All. In K-2 keep it to one sentence. In 9-12 written comments carry more weight than spoken praise.

3. Add "yet" to feedback

When a student says "I can't do this," respond with "You can't do this yet. What have you tried?" Mark work that is not at standard as "not yet" rather than failing, and attach the next step.

Grade band: K-5, use a visible "not yet" tray or folder. 6-12, build it into the rubric language.

4. Make mistakes public and useful

Run a weekly "favorite mistake" routine: pick an anonymous error from student work, project it, and have the class find the thinking that produced it and the fix. Mistakes become data rather than verdicts.

Grade band: 3-12. In K-2, the teacher makes a deliberate mistake and models recovering from it.

5. Model your own struggle out loud

When you hit a hard problem or an unfamiliar question, narrate your thinking: "I'm not sure. Let me try breaking it into parts." Students need to see that competent adults get stuck and recover.

Grade band: All. Secondary teachers can share a current skill they are learning outside school.

6. Set learning goals, not just performance goals

A performance goal is "get an A." A learning goal is "be able to explain why the method works." Have students write one learning goal per unit and check it at the end.

Grade band: 3-12. K-2 students can set "I will learn to..." goals with picture support.

7. Teach strategies, and switch them when effort stalls

Effort is only useful when it is attached to a strategy that can work. Keep a visible menu of strategies for the subject (reread, draw it, try a smaller case, ask a specific question). When a student has worked hard without progress, the coaching move is "That strategy isn't working. Pick another one," not "Try harder."

Grade band: All. The menu changes by subject and age; the move is the same.

8. Build revision into grading

Allow students to revise work after feedback for a higher grade, within limits you can manage. A revision policy tells students that first attempts are drafts and that the standard is what matters, not the speed of reaching it.

Grade band: 3-12. Set a revision window (for example, one week) and require students to annotate what they changed and why.

9. Normalize choosing the hard option

The national study found larger effects where peers valued challenge. Offer two versions of a task, one that practices and one that stretches, and publicly value the choice to stretch regardless of the score.

Grade band: 3-12. In K-2, frame it as "the just-right challenge."

10. Replace fixed self-talk with growth self-talk

Post a two-column chart of fixed and growth statements (see the examples below). When you hear a fixed statement, ask the student to translate it. The goal is not positive thinking; it is accurate thinking about what to do next.

Grade band: All. Middle schoolers often respond better when the chart uses their own words collected anonymously.

11. Use peer models of growth

Ask students to share, in writing or briefly aloud, something they used to find hard and how they got better at it. Similar peers are more convincing than celebrities.

Grade band: 3-12. Keep it voluntary and low-stakes.

12. Give feedback that points to the next step

According to Hattie and Timperley's review, feedback is among the most powerful influences on achievement, but its effect depends on the type and how it is delivered. Feedback that names what to do next ("Add evidence for your second claim") beats a score alone or general praise.

Grade band: All. In 9-12, reserve grades until after students have acted on comments where possible.

13. Reframe tests as information

Before a test, say what it is for: to find out what has been learned and what needs more work. After it, have students sort their errors by cause (did not know, knew but rushed, misread) and plan one action for each type.

Grade band: 3-12. K-2 can sort errors with a teacher in a conference.

14. Audit your own mindset signals

Because teacher beliefs moderated the national study's effects, review your own practice once a term. Do you group by perceived ability in visible ways? Do you comfort struggling students by lowering expectations ("Not everyone is a math person")? Do you let students opt out of challenge? Each of these sends a fixed-mindset signal regardless of what the posters say.

Grade band: Teacher practice, all grades. A colleague observation works better than self-report.

Growth mindset examples for students

Use this table on the wall, in planners or as a warm-up. Each growth statement describes an action, not just a feeling.

Fixed mindset statement Growth mindset translation
"I'm not good at this." "I'm not good at this yet. What strategy haven't I tried?"
"I give up." "I'll use one of the strategies on the board, then ask a specific question."
"This is too hard." "This is going to take time and effort. Which part can I start with?"
"I made a mistake." "Mistakes show me what to work on. What does this one tell me?"
"She's just smarter than me." "I'm going to find out how she approaches it."
"I'll never be good at writing." "My writing has improved since September. Here is what I'll work on next."
"I got a bad grade, so I failed." "The grade tells me what I haven't learned yet. What's my plan?"
"Plan A didn't work." "Plan A didn't work. What will I change for Plan B?"

Watch for the counterfeit version: a student who says "I just need to try harder" while repeating the same failed method. The growth response is a new strategy or a request for help, not more of the same.

A growth mindset curriculum: six-week implementation sequence

Growth mindset is not a unit you teach once. The following sequence front-loads the explicit teaching and then shifts to routines that run all year.

Week Focus What students experience
1 The brain can grow One lesson on how learning changes the brain; students write about a skill they improved.
2 Language Introduce the fixed/growth chart; teacher begins process praise and "yet" consistently.
3 Mistakes Launch the favorite mistake routine; teacher models struggle out loud.
4 Strategies Build the subject strategy menu together; practice switching strategies when stuck.
5 Goals and revision Students set one learning goal; announce the revision policy and model an annotated revision.
6 Challenge norms Introduce two-level tasks; celebrate the stretch choice; students share peer growth stories.

After week six, keep three routines running every week: process feedback on at least one piece of work per student, one favorite mistake session, and one opportunity to revise. Revisit the brain lesson before high-stakes assessments and after any major transition.

How to measure progress

Measure behaviors first, beliefs second. Behaviors are easier to observe and harder to fake.

Behavior indicators to track:

  • Share of students choosing the stretch version of a two-level task.
  • Number of revisions submitted per assignment, and whether revised work improves.
  • Help-seeking: how many students ask a specific question versus wait or give up.
  • Persistence after an error, which you can see in whether work resumes within a minute.
  • Course choices at transition points, such as electing a harder math pathway.

Belief indicators: Short survey items of the kind used in PISA and the national study ask students to agree or disagree with statements such as "Your intelligence is something about you that you can't change very much." Give the same items at the start and end of the semester. Treat the results as a rough signal, not a score; students quickly learn the expected answer, and a single classroom's survey will be noisy. Behavior is your real evidence.

For a school-level approach, see our guide to measuring mindsets, essential skills and habits.

Common pitfalls

  • Posters instead of practice. The research effects came from carefully designed messages followed by supportive classroom conditions. A wall display does nothing on its own.
  • Effort-only praise. Praising effort that produced no progress teaches students that effort is a consolation prize. Pair effort with strategy and outcome.
  • Telling students they can do anything. The accurate message is that abilities can be developed, not that everyone will reach the same level in the same time. Overpromising undermines trust.
  • Blaming students for their mindset. If a student holds fixed beliefs, that is a response to their experiences, often including school. Change the conditions before expecting the belief to change.
  • Expecting large effects. The national study's effects were real but modest. Position growth mindset as one part of good teaching, not a transformation.
  • Teacher fixed mindset. Comforting struggling students by lowering expectations, or sorting students by perceived ability in visible ways, cancels the message. The 2022 teacher-mindset study makes this the single most important condition to get right.
  • Ignoring equity. The students who benefit most are often those who have heard the most fixed-mindset messages about who belongs in advanced work. Widen access to challenge; do not just reassure.

Putting the toolkit to work

Start small: pick two strategies from the list, run them for three weeks, and track one behavior indicator. Add the six-week sequence at the start of a semester or after a transition. Share the student and family handout at a parent conference or back-to-school night so that the language students hear at home matches what they hear in class; our growth mindset guide for parents covers that side in detail.

The original Transforming Education toolkit introduced growth mindset to many US schools as a facilitated professional development session with videos and reflection activities. This page replaces that format with something you can use without a facilitator. For related skills, see our toolkits on self-efficacy and self-management, and the activity ideas in growth mindset activities.

Frequently asked questions

What is a growth mindset, in one sentence?

A growth mindset is the belief that abilities such as intelligence can be developed through effort, effective strategies and help from others, rather than being fixed traits. The term comes from Stanford psychologist Carol Dweck. The belief matters because it changes how a student responds when work gets hard: as a signal to try a new approach rather than as proof of low ability.

Does growth mindset actually improve grades?

Modestly, and mainly for students who are struggling. In the 2019 national experiment published in Nature, a short online program raised lower-achieving ninth graders' core grade point average by 0.10 points and increased advanced math enrollment by 3 percentage points. Meta-analyses find small average effects overall, larger for at-risk students, and effects that depend on whether the classroom supports challenge-seeking.

What is the difference between growth mindset and self-efficacy?

Growth mindset is a belief about whether ability can change at all. Self-efficacy is a belief about whether you can succeed at a specific task right now. A student can believe intelligence grows in general yet doubt they can pass Friday's quiz. The two reinforce each other, and our self-efficacy toolkit covers how to build task-specific confidence through mastery experiences.

Is praising effort enough to build a growth mindset?

No. Praising effort that produced no progress teaches students that trying hard is a consolation prize. Effective process praise names the specific strategy, decision or revision that led to improvement, and when effort is not working it prompts the student to try a different approach or ask for help. This effort-only pattern is often described as a false growth mindset.

How long does it take to see results?

The interventions in the research were brief, often under an hour, but their effects showed up over a semester in grades and course choices, and only in supportive contexts. In your classroom, expect to see behavioral changes first, such as more students choosing harder tasks or revising work, within a few weeks of consistent language and routines. Grade changes take longer.

Can a teacher's own mindset affect students?

Yes. A 2022 analysis of the national study, matching 9,167 student records to 223 math teachers, found that the growth mindset program improved outcomes only for students whose math teachers held growth mindset beliefs themselves. Students cannot act on a growth mindset in a classroom where mistakes are penalized and ability is treated as fixed.

Sources

  1. Mindset: The New Psychology of Success (book page) Penguin Random House (accessed November 7, 2026)
  2. Praise for Intelligence Can Undermine Children's Motivation and Performance (Mueller & Dweck, 1998, Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 75(1)) American Psychological Association (accessed November 7, 2026)
  3. The Perils and Promises of Praise (Dweck, 2007, Educational Leadership 65(2)) ASCD (accessed November 7, 2026)
  4. Implicit Theories of Intelligence Predict Achievement Across an Adolescent Transition (Blackwell, Trzesniewski & Dweck, 2007, Child Development 78(1)) Society for Research in Child Development / Wiley (accessed November 7, 2026)
  5. Students who believe intelligence can be developed perform better (news release on Blackwell et al., 2007) EurekAlert / Society for Research in Child Development (accessed November 7, 2026)
  6. A national experiment reveals where a growth mindset improves achievement (Yeager et al., 2019) Nature (accessed November 7, 2026)
  7. A Growth Mindset Intervention Can Change Students' Grades if School Culture is Supportive (2019 news release) The University of Texas at Austin (accessed November 7, 2026)
  8. Teacher Mindsets Help Explain Where a Growth-Mindset Intervention Does and Doesn't Work (Yeager et al., 2022, Psychological Science 33(1)) SAGE / Association for Psychological Science (accessed November 7, 2026)
  9. To What Extent and Under Which Circumstances Are Growth Mind-Sets Important to Academic Achievement? Two Meta-Analyses (Sisk et al., 2018, Psychological Science) SAGE / Association for Psychological Science (accessed November 7, 2026)
  10. Study finds popular 'growth mindset' educational interventions aren't very effective (2018 news release) Michigan State University (accessed November 7, 2026)
  11. A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of Growth Mindset Interventions: For Whom, How, and Why Might Such Interventions Work? (Burnette et al., 2023, Psychological Bulletin 149(3-4)) American Psychological Association (accessed November 7, 2026)
  12. Why Meta-Analyses of Growth Mindset and Other Interventions Should Follow Best Practices for Examining Heterogeneity (Tipton et al., 2023, Psychological Bulletin) PubMed Central (accessed November 7, 2026)
  13. What Can Be Learned from Growth Mindset Controversies? (Yeager & Dweck, 2020, American Psychologist 75(9)) PubMed Central (accessed November 7, 2026)
  14. Sky's the limit: Understanding the impact of growth mindset (OECD PISA 2018 report page) Yidan Prize Foundation / OECD (accessed November 7, 2026)
  15. Inaugural PISA data on students' growth mindset and teaching practices Thomas B. Fordham Institute (accessed November 7, 2026)
  16. The Power of Feedback (Hattie & Timperley, 2007, Review of Educational Research 77(1)) SAGE / American Educational Research Association (accessed November 7, 2026)